How To Sell More GAP Insurance

Are you leaving money on the table by not maximizing your GAP insurance sales? Many F&I Managers unknowingly miss prime opportunities to boost PVR and better protect their customers. GAP insurance isn’t just another add-on—it’s an essential safety net for today’s car buyers, especially as vehicles become more expensive and depreciation rates accelerate.

Consider this: A dealership recently reviewed its sales data and found that over 75% of deals with loan-to-value (LTV) ratios between 80% and 110% were sold without GAP coverage. That’s a significant revenue loss and, more importantly, a gap (pun intended) in customer protection.

The issue? F&I Managers are often influenced by lender-imposed LTV guidelines and may avoid offering GAP when they shouldn’t. In this article, we’ll break down how to overcome these mental roadblocks, use proven sales techniques, and ultimately sell more GAP insurance the easiest way possible.

Key Takeaways

• Don’t Let Lenders Dictate GAP Sales — Always Calculate LTV

• Leverage Vehicle Depreciation Trends to Illustrate GAP’s Value

• Master the Tried-and-True GAP Graph Technique for Visual Learners

• Combat Common Customer Objections with Strong Counterpoints

What is GAP Insurance and Why is it Crucial?

GAP insurance, or Guaranteed Asset Protection, covers the difference between a vehicle’s actual cash value (ACV) and the remaining loan balance in the event of a total loss. With car prices at all-time highs and depreciation rates accelerating, GAP has never been more critical.

Why GAP is More Relevant Today:

• Vehicle Depreciation Is Faster Than You Think: According to Edmunds, vehicles depreciate an average of 24% in the first year and 15% each subsequent year.

• High-Tech Repairs Are Expensive: Modern vehicles are packed with electronics—by 2030, an estimated 50% of a vehicle’s value will come from electronic components. Even minor accidents can lead to costly repairs, making total losses more common.

• Insurance Companies Cut Corners: Without GAP, insurers will only cover a vehicle’s ACV—leaving the customer responsible for the difference.

How to Sell More GAP Insurance

Step 1: Always Calculate LTV — Even with Big Down Payments

A common misconception among F&I Managers is that a large down payment means the customer doesn’t need GAP. However, even with $10,000 down, customers often finance taxes, fees, and warranties, pushing their LTV higher than expected.

Pro Tip:

• Always calculate the full LTV, including all financed extras.

• Don’t assume—verify. If the LTV is above 80%, GAP is a no-brainer. If it’s close, use it as a talking point.

Example: A dealership discovered that over 75% of deals above 80% LTV didn’t have GAP—until they implemented routine LTV calculations. Within 60 days, GAP penetration increased by 35%, directly boosting PVR.

Step 2: Use the GAP Graph to Appeal to Visual Learners

Roughly 65% of people are visual learners. To close more GAP deals, leverage simple, effective visuals.

How to Use the GAP Graph:

1. Draw Two Lines: One representing the loan payoff (declining over time) and another showing vehicle depreciation (dropping faster).

2. Highlight the Gap: Where the depreciation line dips below the loan payoff is where customers are at financial risk.

3. Make It Personal: Plot the customer’s specific numbers for a powerful, customized impact.

“Here’s your $32,000 loan over 6 years. Based on industry averages, your vehicle could depreciate by 24% in the first year alone. If totaled early, you could owe thousands—unless you have GAP.”

Step 3: Prepare for Common Objections — And Overcome Them with Confidence

Customers often hesitate to buy GAP. Here’s how to address the most frequent objections:

• “I’ll Get It Through My Insurance.”

  • Counterpoint: “Insurance GAP policies often favor the insurer. If your car’s repair costs are close to the total loss threshold, the adjuster may choose to repair it—even if it should be totaled—to save money. With dealership GAP, your financial interests are protected first.”

• “I Don’t Think I’ll Need It.”

  • Counterpoint: “Over 50% of cars depreciate faster than loan payoffs, especially for customers who drive high mileage. One accident could leave you owing thousands.”

• “I Don’t Want to Pay More Per Month.”

  • Counterpoint: “For less than $20 a month, GAP could save you thousands in the event of a total loss. It’s a small price for significant peace of mind.”

Step 4: Leverage Customer-Specific Data to Make GAP Personal

Personalization sells. Use data from the customer’s trade-in, driving habits, and financing details to make your GAP pitch relatable.

Tips for Personalization:

• Review the Trade-In: High-mileage trade-ins indicate the customer drives more than average, increasing depreciation.

• Consider Financing Terms: Longer loans (72-84 months) create a larger potential “gap” over time.

• Ask About Driving Habits: Daily commutes, frequent road trips, or work-related driving all increase risk.

FAQs

1. Why do lenders discourage GAP on low LTV deals?

Lenders limit GAP eligibility to manage risk, but customers still face potential depreciation losses.

2. How does dealership GAP compare to insurance GAP?

Dealership GAP often covers up to 125%-150% of the vehicle’s value and includes deductible coverage, unlike many insurance policies.

3. What’s the easiest way to present GAP without overwhelming the customer?

Use visual aids like the GAP graph and keep the message simple: “This covers the difference if your car is totaled.”

4. What if a customer plans to pay off the loan early?

Many GAP plans offer prorated refunds if paid off early—always check policy details.

5. Do all lenders accept GAP coverage?

Most do, but it’s essential to check specific lender guidelines.

6. What if a customer buys an older, used vehicle?

GAP can still be valuable for used vehicles, especially if the loan term is long or the buyer rolled negative equity into the new loan.

Conclusion

Selling more GAP insurance isn’t just about increasing dealership revenue—it’s about protecting customers from potential financial disasters. By calculating LTV upfront, using visual tools like the GAP graph, and personalizing each pitch, F&I Managers can dramatically increase GAP penetration rates.

The easiest method to sell more GAP? Make it simple, visual, and personal. Your customers will appreciate the added protection, and your PVR will thank you.

By the way, you’re invited to check out our world-class F&I training program where the average F&I Manager increases their PVR by over 30% in the first month. You’ll have access to 100+ hours of training videos personalized to your weaknesses. Plus, you get exclusive access to see Gerry Gould LIVE twice per month to ensure you continue to grow your skillset and income. Come join a community of the top F&I Managers in the country and the #1 F&I Training in the world. For $149 you can pay that off with one extra deal we’ll personally teach you in the first week of training.